RESEARCH ARTICLES: Conversion of Land Use in Vietnam through a Political Economy Lens

Conversion of Land Use in Vietnam through a Political Economy Lens

 (Page 131-146)

Andrew Wells-Dang, Pham Quang Tu and Adam Burke

Abstract: Land tenure in Vietnam is becoming increasingly contested in the context of rapid economic development and growing inequality. Agricultural land in and around cities is targeted by developers for conversion to commercial uses. In rural areas, farmers’ access to productive land is restricted by the prevalence of state-owned farms and forest enterprises. As a result, the number of complaints filed over land issues has increased dramatically in the last decade, and the revision of the Land Law in 2013 led to an unprecedented level of public participation in land policy formation. 

This article applies a political economy approach to processes of agricultural land conversion through analysis of the interests and incentives of key actors within and outside the Vietnamese state; the gap between legal documents and policy implementation; and processes of interaction among multiple stakeholders over time. Data sources include monitoring of official media and blogs, interviews with officials and experts, and direct experience in coalition building. The authors present case studies of successful and less successful local advocacy around land issues. In the discussion and conclusion sections, the article explores the extent to which emerging narratives of farmers’ rights may challenge the model of economic growth through resource extraction.

Keywords: Land; political economy; economic development; advocacy.

References

An Dien. 2012. "Major land crisis looms large", Thanh Nien, 3 February.

 http://www.thanhniennews.com/society/major-land-crisis-looms-large-8437.html, accessed 4 May 2015.

CECODES, Viet Nam Fatherland Front, and UNDP. 2015. The Viet Nam Provincial Governance and Public Administration Performance Index (PAPI) 2014: Measuring citizens’ experiences. Hanoi.

Centre for Agricultural Policy (CAP), Vietnam Farmers’ Union, Vietnam Chamber of Commerce and Industry (VCCI), and Advancement of Community Empowerment and Partnership (ACEP). 2013. Land Consolidation for Poor People in Vietnam. Report Summary, October.

Copestake, J. and R. Williams. 2012. The Evolving Art of Political Economy Analysis: Unlocking its Practical Potential Through a More Interactive Approach. Oxford Policy Management. http://www.opml.co.uk/sites/opml/files/The%20evolving%20art%20of%20political%20economy%20analysis%20-%20Development%20Futures%20February%202012.pdf, accessed 15 January 2013.

Dang Hung Vo. 2009. ‘Improving Land Acquisition and Voluntary Land Conversion in Vietnam’. World Bank, Hanoi.

Dang Linh. 2015. "70% đơn khiếu nại, tố cáo liên quan đến đất đai" [70% of complaints and denunciations relate to land], Government of Vietnam webpage, 31 March.

 http://baodientu.chinhphu.vn/hoat-dong-bo-nganh/70-don-khieu-nai-to-cao-lien-quan-den-dat-dai/223712.vgp, accessed 4 May 2015.

Embassy of Denmark, World Bank, and Embassy of Sweden. 2011. Recognizing and reducing corruption risks in land management in Vietnam. Hanoi: National Political Publishing House.

Government of Vietnam. 2015. "Báo cáo số 70/BC-CP của Chính phủ về tình hình thực hiện chính sách, pháp luật về quản lý, sử dụng đất tại các nông lâm trường quốc doanh giai đoạn 2004- 2014" [Government Report to the Politburo on implementation of laws and policies on management and land use of state farms and forest enterprises, 2004-14], 9 March.

GRAIN. 2015. "Asia's agrarian reform in reverse: laws taking land out of small farmers' hands", blog posting.

            http://www.grain.org/article/entries/5195-asia-s-agrarian-reform-in-reverse-laws-taking-land-out-of-small-farmers-hands, accessed 4 May 2015.

Hansen, Kaitlin. 2013. "Land Law, Land Rights, and Land Reform in Vietnam: A Deeper Look into “Land Grabbing” for Public and Private Development."’ SIT Graduate Institute Independent Study Project report.

Hirsch, Philip, Marie Mellac, and Natalia Scurrah. 2015. "The Political Economy of Land Governance in Vietnam". Vientiane: Mekong Region Land Governance Project.

Kerkvliet, Benjamin J. Tria. 2005. The Power of Everyday Politics: How Vietnamese Peasants Transformed National Policy. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.

Khan, Mahmood Hassan. 2000. "Rural Poverty in Developing Countries", Finance and Development 37(4), December.

http://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/fandd/2000/12/khan.htm, accessed 4 May 2015.  

Landa. 2013. "Grassroots Consultation for Amendment of the Revised Land Law: Stories from the Field".

Nguyen Khac Vien. 2002. Vietnam: A Long History, 5^th ed. Hanoi: The Gioi Publishers.

Nguyen Van Giap. 2013. Political Economy Analysis of Farmers’ Cooperatives and Organizations for Market Participation in Vietnam. Hanoi: Oxfam.

Nguyen, Vinh Quoc. 2014. "Vietnam’s New Land Law: The Impact on Foreign Investors".

Oxfam. 2012a. "Strengthen community voices for informed choices: Land-use and land-use change in central Vietnam", May.

Oxfam. 2012b. "Land-use and land-use conversion: Policy asks and background paper", internal programme document, August.

Oxfam and Oxford Policy Management. 2015. "Coalition Support Programme Review of Political Economy Analysis", June.

Oxfam and Oxford Policy Management. 2012. "Vietnam Political Economy Analysis Summary Report", December.

Phuc Hau. 2015. "Xây dựng HTX kiểu mới giúp nông dân làm giàu" [New-model cooperatives help farmers improve income], Sai Gon Giai Phong newspaper, 11 April, p. 6.

Reuters (2012) ‘Vietnam detains 20 in latest land clash - media,’ 25 April. http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/04/25/vietnam-land-clash-idUSL3E8FP50120120425, accessed 4 May 2015.

Tran, Tuyet Nhung, Hoang Cam, Le Thanh Sang, Nguyen Thi Phuong Cham, Ngo Thi Phuong Lan and Vu Thanh Long. 2012. The Exclusion of Women’s Access to Land in Contemporary Việt Nam. United Nations Development Programme.

Trinh, Hong-Loan and McCluskey, William J. 2012. Property Tax Reform in Vietnam: A Work in Progress. Toronto: Institute on Municipal Finance & Governance (Working Paper No. 8).

Tuoi Tre. 2012. "Land should be priced by independent rating entity: expert", 24 September.

Vietnam Briefing. 2014. "Vietnam’s Land Law Goes Into Effect, More Room for FIEs", blog posting, 4 July.

 http://www.vietnam-briefing.com/news/vietnams-land-law-goes-effect-room-fies.html, accessed 4 May 2015.

Vietnam Development Report. 2010. Modern Institutions. Joint Donor Report to the Vietnam Consultative Group Meeting, 3-4 December 3-4, Hanoi.

Vietnam News. 2015a. "Local firms buy into agriculture", 9 April, p. 15.

Vietnam News. 2015b. "Co-operatives come under review", 13 April, p. 2.

Wells-Dang, Andrew. 2013. "Promoting Land Rights in Vietnam: A Multi-Sector Advocacy Coalition Approach", paper presented at the World Bank Conference on Land and Poverty, Washington DC, April.

Wild, Leni, David Booth, Clare Cummings, Marta Foresti, and Joseph Wales. 2015. "Adapting development: Improving services for the poor". London: Overseas Development Institute.

Wong, Chian Voen and Nguyen Van Hai. 2015. "Will Vietnam Sink or Swim Amid a Proliferation of FTA?" Mayer Brown Legal Article, 16 February.http://www.mayerbrown.com/Will-Vietnam-Sink-or-Swim-Amid-a-Proliferation-of-FTA-02-16-2015/ accessed 4 May 2015.

 http://journal.ussh.vnu.edu.vn/index.php/vjossh/article/view/52